I oppose totally the vote in the Irish Dail on Wednesday night last to recognise a Palestine State. Why is this such a big issue anyway? It is big because it gives power to a major lie that has hit humanity in general. That is that there are a people called the Palestinians and that they have always existed. The reality and answer to this lie is that up until 1948 the Arabs in Palestine were not calling themselves “Palestinians” at all and did not even like to be called that name or anything to do with “Palestine”. The ONLY people calling themselves that were Jews and usually called Palestinian Jews. The Arabs called themselves well—Arabs!


The second part of this big lie is that the leader of the 1948 war against Israel was a man called Hajj Amin el Husseini and only 3 years before this leader was in Germany leading in the murdering of 6 million Jews. All mention of Hajj Amin el Husseini is removed from all reports and writings in Ireland on this issue.


And the third issue is that the Irish especially Sinn Fein have abandoned Irish nationalism and no longer are fighters for Irish nationalism. The “Palestinian” issue for Adams is therefore a diversion to his own betrayal of the Irish. Furthermore every Irish person knows very well this betrayal of nationalism by Adams.


There is one further issue. That is Israeli leadership. It is bankrupt. The Israelis and the Jews are now a people without a leadership which can match up to the challenges of the present and the coming struggles.


The Israelis are led by elites when they must be led now by revolutionaries.


I say this most definitely. There is only one way forward in the midst of this almost incredible crisis for Jews and Israel (Yes I know there are Israelis who do not care or do not pay attention to these votes) But they are wrong on that as well. These votes matter greatly.


Remember that the American ruling elites are always hostile to the Jews and have kept Jonathon Pollard in prison now for 30 years.


All that Pollard did was to give information to Israel about dangers to Israel from Iranian threats to the existence of Jews on this earth, information that the American elites were not passing on, a criminal act in itself. And Obama hates Jews totally.


The Jewish elites are betraying Jews as we speak. There is a man in Ireland called Alan Shatter. He is a Jew in the Dail and he did not oppose this vote in the Dail. HE COULD BUT DID NOT VOTE AGAINST IT.


This means that a new leadership must be built in Ireland which will stand in the traditions of revolutionary socialism of Lenin and especially of Leon Trotsky.


And the same must happen in Israel because I am totally dismayed by the sheer bankruptcy of the Israeli elites, such as Netanyahu, Lieberman and Bennett, while there is a distinct traitor class leadership around Livni and Labour as well as Lapid, the latter now being eclipsed by these events.


In fact now the only policy that makes sense and that is being advanced by we Trotskyists on 4international is that Israel must immediately in Ireland call for ULSTER independence, the destruction of the Good Friday Agreement that brought the terrorist sectarians of Sinn Fein into power north and south,


That means in essence building our Trotskyist 4international…the following is taken from the Adams twitter page and shows a photograph taken in the Dail where Palestinain Arabs had met with Sinn Feiners. I think the woman in the yellow coat is called popularly “Mary Lou”,  Adams is in the centre and on the very left is a real Israel hater who used to represent Monaghan 


this is the two state theory summed up in all its gory reality

From the recent Martin Sherman article on Jerusalem Post ( ) there is this paragraph among many memorable paragraphs:


From the newly elected president, Reuven Rivlin, to veteran Police Chief Yohanan Danino, statements explicitly alleging or insinuating that the Jews’ own conduct – such as exercising their right of access to religious sites or legislative initiatives to codify in law the values reflected in the Declaration of Independence – precipitated, or at least, exacerbated, recent Arab butchery of innocent Jews in the streets, on the roads, inside synagogues, and at building sites across the country. – end quote


Rivlin we know. Danino is head since a couple of years ago of ALL of the police in Israel. He is a top dog really! And the type of person elected to be top dog is a man who was behind the persecution of Liberman, the Russian Israeli politician and essentially patriot (despite many issues he is that)


Even this one paragraph throws up serious issue and offers a light into the reality of Israeli elitist betrayal of the Jewish Zionist cause


Meanwhile the various bloggers on sites such as Israpundit and on Sherman’s own Facebook page simply cannot get to terms with the central issue which is ESSENTIALLY totally about leadership and the absence of patriotic leadership which CAN lead.


Sherman himself who is principled does not engage in hero worship of anybody and in the paragraph previous to this alludes to my central point – that it is an overall crisis of leadership of Israel that is at stake. Read this first and carefully before I comment:


One senior public figure after another – not only on the Left of the political spectrum – have come out with declarations that have ranged from regrettably inappropriate, through hopelessly unfounded, to dangerously counter-productive. (end quote)


I do not wish to divert but…Note that Sherman uses this outdated and irrelevant term the “Left” when the issue is one of nationalism and patriotism and not the price of bread. It is a corrupt term leading to corruption of the mind – the worst kind!


But having said that Sherman is very clear! It is as he says and I repeat “not only on the Left of the political spectrum” … that the betrayal of Israel is taking place.


In other words he is saying as I am – It is a total crisis of leadership. As far as true and principled leadership is concerned it is vacuum country.


As I said about a year ago there is a complete vacuum of leadership in Israel where all kinds of (what can I call them lets be charitable) “idiots” creep in


To finish off let me see how Martin Sherman ends his piece and it is the way actually that he ends every piece:


 Unless the Jews convey the unequivocal message that any such challenges will be met with overwhelming force, they will increasingly be the victims of such force at the hands of their Arab adversaries.


There may be those who find this prescription excessively harsh.


Sadly, the only way the Jews can avoid living permanently by the sword is to convey convincingly to the Arabs that they have the resolve to do so. I invite everyone to consider the alternative.


Only Arab despair can bring any hope for peace. (end quote)


I agree with every word in the above but I say in the ABC of politics the above is a very tiny A or (a)


In reality it is really tame because it does not deal at all with power and with the former scenario of the PRESIDENT and the HEAD OF POLICE being absolute scoundrels, and as far as Jewish patriotism is concerned THEY ARE NOT remotely so!




There are just 3 paragraphs to read in the Caroline Glick latest article – again the last three THE ENDING!


After much good analysis about this strange new Netanyahu Bill Caroline ends like this:


Rather than doing the hard work of running a continuous, relentless campaign to accrue the requisite power to reform the system, politicians on the Right have embraced an unnecessary bill that will do nothing to protect Israel’s future.


On the other hand, their counterparts on the Left have shown that the Israeli Left is today largely indistinguishable from the international Left which rejects Israel’s right to exist and rejects the Jewish people’s right to sovereignty and freedom in its homeland. With Haaretz acting as the conduit between the BDS movement and government ministers, politicians on the Left have become unmoored from the basic requirements of national life.


In other words, the current maelstrom over the draft Nation State bill shows that Israel’s political Right is far weaker than it needs to be and that Israel’s political Left is far more destructive than it ought to be.(end quote)


I mean what an ending! What is THAT about!


I feel as if I am in the middle of a large and deep lough and unable to swim and Caroline has planted me there.


There is just no way out of that last sentence of Caroline´s. I am sinking and if this is the best (Caroline) that Israel can do it will sink like a stone.


Israel is in very serious danger and it is not only from the forces of Antisemitism but also from the poorness of leadership inside Israel and of the Israeli state. This is concentrated in the bumbling activity of Netanyahu in his leadership of the Israeli state. Netanyahu needs to be forced out of power but he operates a state dictatorship. His popularity has fallen from the 80s to the present 30s inside the weeks he has been running the Gaza War


By all mathematics if this was a democracy Netanyahu would have packed his bags but there is a clique in power in Israel which is separated from the masses of the people.


Last time I checked Netanyahu was a member of the Likud Party. The immediate question is why Likud has not expelled Netanyahu?


There is a big lesson here. The Likud also refused to expel Sharon when this petty punk decided to disregard the referendum HE called (back in 2005) and which (result of said referendum) opposed him down the line over Gaza Withdrawal.


The EXACT same position now holds.


Netanyahu and his flunkeys are calling the Gaza War as NOT A DEFEAT and that is the BIG LIE.


The Gaza War of 2014 has been an amazing defeat for Israel, for Jews and for all of us like 4international who place the defence of Israel at the forefront of our political work.


Ted Belman is a good guy who runs the blog Israpundit but Ted does not fight against these scumbags one of whom on his site (calling himself “Bernard Ross”) is spinning out this Netanyhau rubbish that the Gaza War has been a victory because it has prolonged the conflict between PA and Hamas


This is reactionary drivel brought into the Jewish movement by agents like Ross. Who cares if you are a proud Jew or supporter like I am, if they fight anong each other or not. That is not our concern. Our business is to smash up this whole Palestinian Arab Antisemitism in total and do it now, without delay.


Here is no solution other than to fight to smash these Antisemites and it is very wrong for Ted Belman of Israpundit not to tear this guy Bernard Ross apart for this ugly genuflection in front of Antisemitism.


The task now is very clear.


The Israeli people have shown in the only way that they can show that they thoroughly dislike Netanyahu and they do not swallow the Netanyahu propaganda as advanced by flunkeys like Bernard Ross.


The Israeli people have been voting in these polls against Netanyahu and everything he stands for.


But what are these great people to do? They have no leadership and flunkeys like this “Bernard Ross” continue their poison, aided by the silence of even patriots like Ted Belman.


The Likud which is the only leadership around continue to sit on their back sides and NOT EXPEL NETANYAHU


So what is Moyse Feiglin doing at this moment. Why is he in this Likud? Why in Likud is he not party to expelling of Netanyhau?


The same with Danny Dayon. And all of these who are saying they dislike what Netanyahu has done BUT KEEP NETANYHAU IN THEIR PARTY.



NOTE poison pumped in by Bernard Ross regular on Israpundit


Did the penny drop?

 this should be interesting if true, the more internal squabbling among them the better: the pal spring?




Unless Israel seeks to annex gaza permanently there is no gain to deposing hamas. Israel’s optimum position is the separation of gaza and PA west bank.




another reason why it is better to keep hamas than abbas /fatah. When abbas dies or retires fatah will choose a new leader and it can be this guy


Gaza Ceasefire: What Did Israel Agree to?





The war with Hamas is well and truly lost and the responsibility lies not with the rank and file soldiers but with the whole political and military elites in Israel. The situation can be summed up as being a case of brave, brave soldier led by pompous fools. (I thought of saying led by donkeys but I will not use such expressions ever again because my politics lead me to respect the animal world. Recently I was barred from the Talk Radio Europe radio phone in because I said the host was speaking “bullshit” and on reflection I was sorry I used that expression because I was ashamed of myself for using a derogatory word implicating a defenseless and innocent animal. In case anybody is interested he is a British Jew called Tindesley and he was saying that the Jews in Morocco were never driven out by the Muslims and that made me instantly angry, so I lost my cool)


I was struck above all at how small is Gaza. Israel too is small (less than the size of Munster) but Gaza is tiny. And there is so much talk in Jewish circles about the great IDF, but that now has to be very much questioned.


Also I was struck by the idea of these Hamas guys going underground. As a military commander I would immediately see that as a major positive for my side. Going underground makes the enemy totally vulnerable.


Totally vulnerable if given certain conditions or certain actions by the IDF. I will divide the response to that question in three ways


  1. What Netanyahu did
  2. What a daring commander would have done
  3. Finally further consideration of these first two points, the first of which in (1) above we know. It is this further consideration that I would like to focus on.


On the question of what Bibi did is very easy to answer. Basically he did nothing (as Martin Sherman demonstrated). Oh of course there were lots being done, soldiers dashing here and there, but as Sherman showed nothing of a strategic nature. So that first question is easy to answer…Bibi did nothing


What a daring commander would have done. The answer lies in what Brian Boru did against the Danes in the Battle of Clontarf in that our Brian took possession of the ground that the Danes were standing on and held on to that ground. So a daring commander would have taken possession of the ground and held on to the ground (of Gaza to start with) For that the Jews need a big thought that is simple, true and understandable for all Jews. The big thought is the Land of Israel and to end Antisemitism in the Land of Israel. This is a BIG thought indeed and it even includes some Jews as well, Haaretz comes to mind.


Now the reflection…the important part.



Israel is not united. Israel does not have a political party to unite it. Because Israel does not have a political party Israel can never unite the vast majority behind a programme. The people of Israel never unite behind a programme. They remain divided. Sometimes as in the Gaza Withdrawal a mass movement develops but because there is no political party the mass movement fades away as reality of defeat sets in



Israelis cannot build a political party to unite under because there is no ideology or theory to unite under. Some of the participants include a man on Shermans blog who calls for a King!!!, Netanyahu who was a furniture salesman not a theoretician, his wife plays a role and she is a housewife, Feiglin is terrific but Feiglin is for Feiglin and Feiglin hates the plebeians, Livni is Livni and Livni just loves living with Antisemitism. The “Labour” Party also loves Antisemitism, The Likudniks can never have any power because they see things as moving through the Knesset, so they tie the Israelis to the Knesset, the Women in Green are conquering the latest hill measured 50 yards by twenty, the Rabbis are reading up on what some bloke wrote about something 2000 years ago, most of the ladies in Tel Aviv seek a tan desparately, and there is hardly anybody that sees the Jews as an iron age people who are part of a long development starting somewhat with “Lucy” and her friends on the Savanna plains


And that is why Netanyahu could not ever develop a strategy to take over Gaza, expel the Antisemites, make an offer to Arabs to love the Jewish Homeland, even make an offer to some to find new homes (they tell me there is lots of space and lovely nature in Mayo!)


Netanyahu has no background (the opposite) to have a strategy or theory even. This issue is beyond him. He is a furniture salesman (and Obama is a third rate University Lecturer and you know what they are like!)


So until this new leadership is built then this war and all future wars against Fascism will be lost, and the Jewish Homeland will fall into great danger of being destroyed. The Barbarians will have defeated this Great Idea.


2010 Pentagon investigation: “incontrovertible” that Bergdahl walked away from his unit


bergdahl2That means the Obama Administration traded five dangerous jihad terror leaders for a known deserter. Will there be a full investigation this time, or will John Boehner start weeping and punt, as always?

“U.S. concluded in 2010 that Bergdahl walked away,” by Ken Dilanian and Deb Riechmann, Associated Press, June 2, 2014:

A Pentagon investigation concluded in 2010 that Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl walked away from his unit, and after an initial flurry of searching the military decided not to exert extraordinary efforts to rescue him, according to a former senior defense official who was involved in the matter.

Instead, the U.S. government pursued negotiations to get him back over the following five years of his captivity — a track that led to his release over the weekend.



Bergdahl was being checked and treated Monday at a U.S. military hospital in Germany as questions mounted at home over the swap that resulted in his freedom in exchange for the release of five detainees who were sent to Qatar from the U.S. prison at Guantanamo, Cuba.



Even in the first hours of Bergdahl’s handoff to U.S. special forces in eastern Afghanistan, it was clear this would not be an uncomplicated yellow-ribbon celebration. Five terrorist suspects also walked free, stirring a debate over whether the exchange would heighten the risk of other Americans being snatched as bargaining chips and whether the released detainees — several senior Taliban figures among them — would find their way back to the fight….



And in Kabul Monday, the Afghan Foreign Ministry called the swap “against the norms of international law” if it came against the five imprisoned Taliban detainees’ will. The ministry said: “No state can transfer another country’s citizen to a third country and put restriction on their freedom.”

Tireless campaigners for their son’s freedom, Bob and Jani Bergdahl thanked all who were behind the effort to retrieve him. “You were not left behind,” Bob Bergdahl told reporters, as if speaking to his son. “We are so proud of the way this was carried out.” He spoke in Boise, Idaho, wearing a long bushy beard he’d grown to honor his son, as residents in the sergeant’s hometown of Hailey prepared for a homecoming celebration.



The five detainees left Guantanamo aboard a U.S. military aircraft flying to Qatar, which served as go-between in the negotiations. They are to be banned from leaving Qatar for at least a year. Among the five: a Taliban deputy intelligence minister, a former Taliban interior minister with ties to the late al-Qaida leader Osama bin Laden and a figure linked by human rights monitors to mass killings of Shiite Muslims in Afghanistan in 2000 and 2001.



Questions persisted, too, about the circumstances of Bergdahl’s 2009 capture. Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel declined to comment on earlier reports that the sergeant had walked away from his unit, disillusioned with the war. Such matters “will be dealt with later,” Hagel said.

But the former Pentagon official said it was “incontrovertible” that he walked away from his unit.

The military investigation was broader than a criminal inquiry, this official said, and it didn’t formally accuse Bergdahl of desertion. In interviews, members of his unit portrayed him as a naive, “delusional” person who thought he could help the Afghan people by leaving his army post, the official said.



U.S. military and intelligence agencies had made every effort to monitor Bergdahl’s location and his health, the official said, through both signals intelligence and a network of spies.

Nathan Bradley Bethea, who served as an officer in Bergdahl’s unit, said in an article Monday on the Daily Beast website that Bergdahl was not on patrol, as some reports have suggested.

“There was no patrol that night,” he wrote. “Bergdahl was relieved from guard duty, and instead of going to sleep, he fled the outpost on foot. He deserted. I’ve talked to members of Bergdahl’s platoon_including the last Americans to see him before his capture. I’ve reviewed the relevant documents. That’s what happened.”…







Obama has liberated these Taliban killers of Afghans essentially and he has also liberated this traitor American who obviously with his Father will work to extend the Jihad in America.


This situation in America fast developing but which isunclear to many of us because of much obfuscation, with very dangerous asides, see my post on Pamela Geller website (will place it below) has to be understood along with this in Europe and this very useful report from Commentary


(begin extract here)


The revelation that the Belgium police have now made an arrest in relation to the recent shooting at the Jewish museum in Brussels, and more significantly that the suspect is a Muslim radical who spent time fighting in Syria, confirms what many had suspected about that attack; that it was the work of Islamic militancy and the Jew-hatred that constitutes a core aspect of that ideology. When a similar shooting attack took place in 2012 at a Jewish school in Toulouse, much of the media initially attempted to speculate that this was the work of a far-right white supremacist. No doubt the liberal media was holding out for such a result this time too. But in both cases these attacks were the work of home-grown Islamic extremism. These acts may for the moment only concern a very small number of radicalized individuals, yet such individuals emerge from a much wider sub-culture of hate that Europe’s elites not only attempt to ignore, but that is even excused and legitimated by the prevailing narrative in Europe.


The suspect in question has been named as 29-year old French national Mehdi Nemmouche, who spent a year fighting with rebels in Syria. It’s not as if there haven’t been enough warnings about the dangers represented by the phenomenon of large numbers of European Muslims going to fight in Syria, but if European governments have proven incapable of preventing these individuals from making their way to Syria, then one also has to wonder how they were so easily able to slip back into Europe. Still, the case of the Toulouse shooting provides a noteworthy parallel. The gunman in that case, Mohammed Merah, had already spent time in Afghanistan and Pakistan and now it is widely believed that Merah’s sister Souad is also currently in Syria.


It is more than just a little revealing that so many of Europe’s Muslims are drawn to fight for Islamic causes in far off countries in the first place; there are an estimated 600 French Muslims fighting in Syria and almost as many from Britain. It is similarly telling that when these people return they not only continue to engage in acts of violence, but that their violence is directed toward Jews. Of course we shouldn’t ignore the violence against Jews coming from Muslims who haven’t first been radicalized via Syria or elsewhere; on the same day as the shooting in Brussels two French Jews were assaulted in Paris as they were leaving a synagogue. There is hardly space here to rehearse all the recent incidents from Europe of Muslims attacking Jews, but a European Union survey from the fall exposed how in most European countries Muslims were by far the leading group responsible for anti-Semitic incidents, closely followed by individuals identified as being on the far left.


Europe’s elites have proven completely incapable of confronting and tackling this worsening phenomenon because they are incapacitated by a worldview that barely even allows them to openly acknowledge the problem. Most types of racism and bigotry in Europe have been swept away not by government legislation but by a culture of political correctness imposed by Europe’s media and cultural institutions that sets such views beyond the pale. Yet because that very doctrine of political correctness holds immigrant communities and particularly Muslims to be a victim group of the highest order, it has become impossible for Europeans to imagine that these people might themselves be the perpetrators of racism and bigotry. The model doesn’t allow for such a notion, especially not when the victims are Jews. Since Europeans perceive Jews as being white, Western, and affluent, that places them on the side of the oppressors and not among the oppressed.


Then there is the Israel factor. As much as critics of Israel like to stress that it’s Zionists and not Jews they take issue with, whenever Jews are attacked, liberals and liberal Europeans inevitably make the Israel connection and in so doing invalidate their own pretense that they view the two as being entirely separate. When Jewish children were mowed down by bullets as they made their way to school in Toulouse and the EU’s Foreign Policy Chief Catherine Ashton was obliged to concoct some words of sympathy, she stunned observers by using this event to note how, “we see what is happening in Gaza.” It seems that for people like Ashton, it is impossible to acknowledge Jewish victimhood without also footnoting Palestinian suffering, as if in some attempt to explain away whatever has just been done to the Jews in question.


European liberals delight in expressing horror and gleeful outrage at the sight of American Evangelical Christianity. They warn against reactionary Christian attitudes on any social issue that arises in their own country and they are always sure to castigate the Catholic Church whenever the opportunity presents itself (Pope Benedict’s visit to London was marred by large and angry protests). But if Europeans were really concerned about ultra-conservative religious extremism then they would act to prevent the proliferation of radical Islam in Europe. Similarly, if they were serious about ending racism then they would crack down on the only form of racism in Europe today that still kills people: Islamic Jew-hatred.

Tom Watson on Commentary



4international does not just observe and write. Today I broke connection with the Martin Sherman Facebook page. Not because of any difference with Sherman. But it is a con…the whole Facebook thing is a con. Yesterday I placed a post on BDS in Ireland…important really important stuff for all Jews and all of us…Result NOT ONE comment. Now that is farcical!


I am not interested, really not interested, in going through the forms…4international is going to intervene in order to challenge these Fascist BDS types in Ireland and the 5000 friends of Sherman WERE NOT INTERESTED!!!








4international asks directly what is the political programme of Jewish Leadership towards Iran Nuclear?

The world is facing an amazingly complex and uttterly dangerous situation as the pages of any serious political blog will show (not only


These are key issues:


The economic crisis which means that youth unemployment is unsolvable within capitalism. This is also causing mass movements of people such as from Africa to Europe

The growth of Antisemitism and the way that this growth in Antisemitism is disguised by hatred of Israel

The issue of Iran and the danger of extreme Islam producing a Nuclear Bomb


The issue of Israeli leadership is a different issue because this is an issue that can be resolved through building new leadership. The question is to find agreement in doing that.


On the face of it, therefore, the immediate danger of Iran stockpiling enough enriched uranium for a nuclear bomb is over and a sigh of relief should now follow US Secretary of State John Kerry’s warning to a Senate committee a week ago that Iran had enough enriched uranium to start building a bomb within two months.

That being the case, the military option for curtailing the Iranian nuclear threat should be set aside and the six world powers and Tehran can resume their negotiations on May 5 for putting the final touches on a comprehensive accord for finally putting their nuclear controversy to rest.   

But only on the face of it: This scenario ignore Tehran’s duplicity and conveniently passes over the sudden spurt in Iran’s production of low, 5-percent grade enriched uranium and the covert smuggling of the surfeit to the Parchin military facility of near Tehran for its secret upgrade to 20 percent, a level which can be rapidly enriched to weapons grade.
So with one hand, Tehran has reduced its low-grade enriched uranium stocks, but with the other, has smuggled a sizable quantity of those stocks for further enrichment to a facility barred to nuclear watchdog inspectors.

debkafile’s intelligence sources reveal that 1,300 kilos of low-grade material has been transferred to Parchin and 1,630 advanced centrifuges have been installed there for rapid upgrade work.
Whenever the IAEA applied for permission to inspect the facility in the past three years, it was fobbed off with the pretext that Parchin was strictly a military base which did not host any nuclear activity. It therefore did not qualify for international inspection.’s-Arak-“deal”-–-cover-up-for-1-300-kg-enriched-uranium-smuggled-to-Parchin-for-secret-upgrade


The question now is what is the position of all Jewish leadership towards this situation in Iran?


I ask directly what is the political programme to meet this situation?


by Felix Quigley

What actually happened in the murder scene itself has been described in great detail by Israel National News website. Continue reading


by Felix Quigley 

In Part 1 we pointed to the implications of the murder of the Jewish students in Jerusalem 2 days ago. In this article we point to the implications of the great socialist revolutionary Leon Trotsky’s call for a Jewish Homeland where Jews would be free from antisemitism Continue reading


by Felix Quigley

The callous and cowardly murder by an Islamofascist Arab antisemite in Jerusalem two days ago raises the most revolutionary questions in front of us on 4international, representing as we do alone the revolutionary socialist tradition of Leon Trotsky before he was murdered by a Stalinist assassin. Continue reading