English: Palestinian territories (West Bank an...

English: Palestinian territories (West Bank and Gaza Strip) showing Israel’s 1948 and 1967 borders (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

The very important Jewish writer Caroline Glick has reported ona  conference in Jerusalem in which Mrs Livni has stated her innermost political ideas, thoughts and strategy…Yes Livni does have a kind of strategy.


Livni and this Brand of politician in Israel, Lapid is another, are like certain animals which can inject poison, and Livni and her like are always poised to lash out with their poison to try to disable real Jewish patriots.


I have included some points on the general situation surrounding Livni and these pernicious talks for consideration on Israpundit.


I do not mean these to be comprehensive. For example keep in mind the work done by Richard Landes in exposing Pallywood and how the Media including the Israeli Media actually works. But  these points are about leadership. I want to build a Trotskyist party, however small at first.


1. Livni is in conversation with the PA, but this PA, Fatah or Hamas, are the descendents of the Nazis and Hajj Amin el Husseini, who supervised the Holocaust along with Hitler, Himmler and Eichmann
2. For Obama there can be only one end result which is a Palestinian Arab State, but for all capitalist governments Jewish ideas pose a problem (Gil White)
3. Netanyahu runs scared of world opinion
4. Netanyahu considers all the time the attack on Iran to stop the bomb
5. Netanyahu thinks it is a valid strategy to quiet world opinion to give room for attack on Iran´s bomb
6. As capitalist economic crisis gets worse Obama considers need for one success, the “settlement”
7. Jews as scapegoat, Antisemitism, pushes itself to forward position in every country in the world
8. Key role of revisers of Marx, the present “Left”
9. Leadership needed based on perspective but also “boldness”
10. Need to hammer home a clear perspective, which is also a guide to every action, that Judea and Samaria, Jerusalem its unity, is not a matter for “settlers”, but for a united Israel
11. Refuse to be pushed into a corner
12. How to stop being pushed into a corner
13. As capitalist system collapses in on itself what will be role of left
14. What is the historical role of the working class in this present period?




By Caroline Glick, JPOST

For Justice Minister Tzipi Livi, all politics are personal.

She can be trusted, because she is good. Her opponents must be rejected, because they are evil.

In her speech at The Jerusalem Post’s Diplomatic Conference in Herzliya last Thursday, Livni insisted that the only “legitimate” basis for opposing a Palestinian state is ideological. Livni stridently rejected the notion that one can oppose the establishment of a Palestinian state – in the two-state solution framework – for security reasons.

As she sees it, everyone cares equally about security. And since she cares about security just as much as her political opponents do, the question of whose policy will better protect the country is illegitimate. She’s nice. She cares. So she’s just as competent as the next guy.

There’s just one problem with Livni’s claim.

She has a track record.

ISRAEL ENACTED two major strategic initiatives that have her signature on them: the 2005 withdrawal from Gaza, and UN Security Council Resolution 1701 from 2006 that set the terms for the end of the Second Lebanon War.

Both were massive failures. Both caused Israel’s national security to deteriorate. And in both cases, Livni’s political opponents warned that her strategies were wrong-headed, dangerous and unhinged from strategic realities.

Livni built her career on her support for the withdrawal of all Israeli civilians and security forces from the Gaza Strip.

It was her decision to jump on the expulsions bandwagon, and her fervent castigation and demonization of all her former colleagues and voters, that caused then prime minister Ariel Sharon to promote her from a the backwaters of the Absorption Ministry to center stage at the Justice Ministry.

Within months Livni became second only to Ehud Olmert in seniority in Sharon’s government.

As justice minister, Livni ignored the law and trounced democratic norms to repress opponents of the withdrawal.

Licensed buses transporting law abiding citizens to legal protests were unlawfully intercepted en route by police.

Protest organizers were subjected to warrantless, middle-of-the-night searches, unlawful seizure of private property and arbitrary arrests without charge.

13-year-old girls were arrested for participating in protests. They were jailed for four months without charges being brought against them.

And Livni, who since her 2003 ideological transformation from nationalist to radical leftist has presented herself as the guardian of Israeli democracy, oversaw the entire process.

We know what happened after Israel withdrew from Gaza. Just as all of Livni’s opponents warned, Israel was shelled by more rockets, mortars and missiles than ever before. Tel Aviv and Jerusalem are now in range of Gaza’s terror armies.

Hamas took over Gaza, and transformed it into a hub for the global jihad, linking the jihad against Israel to the jihad against Egypt and the rest of the world.

Gaza, which before the withdrawal was never more than a tactical nuisance, became a regional strategic threat.

As the war the next year showed, Israel’s decision to cut and run from Gaza, and its willingness to forcibly expel ten thousand of its most productive citizens from their homes, was a profound expression of weakness. Just as the withdrawal opponents warned, it invited the aggression that Hezbollah visited on us.

As foreign minister during the war, Livni was responsible for organizing Israel’s diplomatic defense and managing relations with the US and Europe.

She chose a strategy of preemptive capitulation. Against the will of prime minister Ehud Olmert, Livni began negotiating the cease-fire in the early days of the war, vacuously insisting that there was no military solution to a terrorist organization’s war of aggression.

The result of her dubious efforts was 1701, which from Israel’s perspective is arguably the most problematic Security Council resolution ever passed. Not only did 1701 treat Hezbollah, a terrorist organization that fought an illegal war against Israel, as a legitimate party simply by ignoring it. It made Hezbollah the victor in the war by ensuring it would retake control of Lebanon’s border with Israel without any serious opposition.

THESE TWO strategic initiatives are Livni’s national security track record. As their failures show, whatever her intentions may be, she is totally incompetent to understand, secure or advance Israel’s national security.

From her egomaniacal insistence that she is The One who will bring the peace, it is apparent that Livni has never accepted responsibility for the damage she has caused the country.

But she does seem to recognize that she cannot defend her actions on their merits. Just as the only card she plays in her favor is egomaniacal self-aggrandizement, so the only card she plays against her opponents is aggressive demonization.

Sunday the cabinet approved the release of another 26 terrorist murderers from prison. The release is second of four tranches that will bring about the release of 104 terrorist murderers from prison. This is the price that Livni and US Secretary of State John Kerry convinced Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu to pay for the privilege of having Livni sit across a negotiating table from Palestinian chief negotiator Saeb Erekat.

In a bid to block the cabinet decision, on Saturday night the Jewish Home (Bayit Yehudi) party released a statement saying that Israel mustn’t endanger the public just so that Livni can sit at a table with chief Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat.

The statement attracted a lot of media attention because it was on the mark.

Livni’s negotiations are endangering Israel’s national security. Hundreds of Israelis have been murdered over the years by terrorists Israel released early from prison for political reasons. More will certainly be murdered by those now being released.

And that isn’t all. The act of releasing terrorists emboldens other terrorists to strike. When they see these murderers welcomed home as heroes after serving a fraction of their life sentences, wouldbe murderers understand that they have a free hand to kill Jews.

Then there are the lessons the Palestinians have learned over 20 years of negotiations. They know that Israel deals with terrorism with kid gloves when negotiations are taking place. Out of fear of angering their Palestinian “partners” Israel’s leaders have consistently failed to take effective action against terrorist attacks that occur while the PLO is supposedly talking peace with us.

So just by sitting down with Erekat, Livni is constraining the freedom of action of the IDF to protect the country.

The recent spate of terrorist attacks, and the IDF’s timid response to them, made this clear, yet again.

The Jewish Home party’s statement neatly encapsulated all of these incontrovertible charges. Since she has no substantive defense against them, she responded with rank demonization and criminalization.

Speaking to Army Radio, Livni’s surrogate, Environmental Protection Minister Amir Peretz, said, “The Jewish Home party has become a messianic and extremist home. The incitement and hatemongering is egregious…. Angry statements like this… can lead to murder.”

AND THERE you have it. Livni, the egomaniacal failure, is competent because she says she cares; and her opponents, who were right about the Gaza withdrawal, right about 1701 and are right about the terrorist releases and the negotiations, are murderers.

Livni promised the audience at the conference last Thursday that she will never quit politics again. Let’s hope her word on that score is as solid as her national security credentials.


As we move quickly towards the eventful Kristallnacht75 (November 9-10) it is clear to me that the Zionist movement of Israel has completely lost its bearings, from especially the hay day of Herzl, and is both confused and politically bankrupt as it moves towards this great commemoration and event. Posed in front of the Jews is again a great killing of the Jews which could well be at the hands of an Iranian Nuclear Bomb, which we can now say is being sponsored by Barack Obama, which the Media and sections of the American population placed in power. Where the Zionist bourgeois pundits of today are making the big mistake is to see Obama as something new, when in fact he is only the continuation of the other Presidents, and especially of George Bush Junior. In fact Sharon opposed the Bush invasión of Iraq, and told Bush so, but he did not announce his opposition publicly, and that is the essence of the problema, these Zionist leaders can never break openly with capitalism. So even though Sharon KNEW that the Iraqi invasión by Bush would be disastrous for Israel, because he kept it PRIVATE, the majority of Jewish Zionist leaders were giving confusing messages tot he whole world, even more fatal.


It is almost unbelievable that Israeli leaders are now in talks with the descendents of Hajj Amin el Husseini in the form of Abbas, the PLO, Hamas in the background, the Muslim Brotherhood everywhere, and that these talks are taking place in order to slice a huge part of historical Israel away from the Jews, that is of course Judea and Samaria. Note that 4international insists as a Trotskyist movement in saying JUDEA and SAMARIA and not the West Bank. As Aaron Klein says the west bank of what, of only the place known as Jordan, previously Transjordan, which was tricked away from the Jews by the British via the British Mandate, because the San Remo Treaty of 1920 which predated the formal Mandate made (1924) present Jordan part of the Jewish Homeland. Now these despicable Zionist leaders of today like Netanyahu and Livni are even trading a slice of what is left, in the hopes of what, that Arab Palestinians will set up a state and live at peace with Jews, some hope!, when that state by demand of Abbas and these Arab Palestinians will be Judenfrei. Thus these Arab Palestinians complete the circle, they were created by the Nazis (Hajj Amin el Husseini), they are descended from the Nazis, they wish to kill Jews, Arab Palestinian Nationalism is THAT sort of nationalism, it can never be called national liberaation in any sense.


But Zionism does remain the national liberation of the Jews. The main problem is simply one of leadership. These present leaders of Zionism have betrayed the national liberation of the Jews. In the second half of the 1930s Leon Trotsky explained Fascism accurately, that the Fascism of the Nazis meant that Jews had to get out of Europe, that Jews would get no help from the Governments of the world, and that the Jews had to reach Palestine and thereby defend themselves from what he called, specifically, Mohammedanism. Anybody who says that Trotsky was or would ever be sympathetic to Arab Palestinians is telling a lie. Otherwie why would he be warning not only about the German Nazis but also about the Arab Islamists.


One of the most serious aspects of the crisis of the Zionist leaders of today is that they are promoters of the bankrupt capitalist system, and thus they are also active on behalf of the movement of capitalism to encircle and destroy both China and Russia, because although these are now capitalist countries, they are still the places where the socialist revolution surfaced. This is the great weakness and indeed downright counter revolutionary nature of people like Caroline Glick. No matter how many good things Glick says, and she does, she is still a pro capitalist hater of the Russian Revolution simple as that.


A new leadership is needed. 4international over many years has a very proud history. We have always defended Zionism as a national liberation movement. But Zionism must be tied tot he world revolutionary socialist movement and away from religious obscurantism if it is to give real leadership to the Jews. We say as a solution Keep you old religión if you want, certainly in every way keep your Jewish culture, but do not try to stop Jews from learning politics. On the other hand…We said defend Mubarak against the Muslim Brotherhood and Obama, we said defend Ben Ali, Gadhafi, Gaghbo, Assad, all of these against the Muslim Brotherhood and Obama. These positions meant that we became close in practice at many times to Jewish Zionist libertarians like Pamela Geller and many others too.


We said also defend Milosevic on the same basis, against Izetbegovic and against Clinton.


Very simply the Zionist leaders, and Caroline Glick is a very good example of this, were unable to take a single one of these positions. Now we say that immediately Netanyahu must withdraw Livni and above all himself and his government from these talks. Netanyahu must break totally and in public from Obama because Obama is clearly sponsoring the Iranian Nuclear Bomb. What precisely is Feiglin doing except refusing to make these calls. When Glenn Beck went to Israel to support the Jews feiglin opposed him because he was a Christian. Now the Christians are being massacred and these Zionist leaders are largely quiet. Israel should now be at the Forefront of the fight to defend Assad and insisting that Assad break from Hezbollah and Iran. Israel needs to also be quite explicit in defending and supporting the Egyptian Military because they find themselves in a life and death struggle against the Muslim Brotherhood, against Hamas and Iran, and essentially against Abbas.


As regards Abbas this is the clearest sign that present Zionism is bankrupt. There is no alternative to a fight. The Arabs are still based on the ideas of the Nazis, that the Jews are evil, and that the Jews must be eliminated as in the Holocaust. Arrest and expel Abbas for the crime of Holocaust Denial.


As we approach Kristallnacht 75 that simple true fact has not ever sunk in except among a few.


We on 4international repeat…there is never any other alternative…you have to fight to defend what is your right. This means immediate changes in Israel. Jews must see that they are in no way special. That the idea that they were chosen by some supernatural being is a laugh. That Jews are simply one brave nation and are part of humanity as equals, and as equals we all face a capitalist system which drive US ALL Jew and non Jew towards dictatorship. The enemy of all of us is the Muslim Brotherhood and the machinations of the NED and other forces of American Imperialism, which are having such an effect on our lives.


Furthermore Jews must at last begin to see the truth…which is that rather tan being “chosen” they are part of humanity, and that human beings are no more than animals, part of the animal and vegetable world, the real world. That is we humans, and every Jew that ever lived, is an animal, an animal with a larger brain, and that humans did not get that brain by choice, but rather much more by accident. Now humans with our large brains under capitalism will destroy the world in following the profit motive, and under socialist, that is the socialist DICTATORSHIP of the proletariat, will save the world and créate a real heaven on earth.


That is the only road for all Jews and for all humans.


Join and build, the only Trotskyist movement in the world today.


Israel cannot simply sit and wait while Obama and Putin provide the cover for Iran to equip itself with 20% enriched plutonium.

We should say with a large quantiry of 20% enriched plutonium.

Say to simplify that quantity produces enough to make 20 or 30 Nuclear Bombs, then what has to brought into the picture is that Iran has made great progress in developing the rocketry to deliver.

Add to that the real certainty that Iran has been working on suitcase type Nuclear Bombs. This is certain because at the centre of Iranian thinking has always been and is suicide bombers.


Obama, the black man with the lovely daughters, so loved by the Media, has Split the world apart and his actions threaten the human race.

Israel and Netanyahu know very well that they cannot influence Obama in the slightest. They know that Iran is now home and dried with Obama and Netanyahu at the side of Iran.

They know that Iran now virtually has the Nuclear Bombs to threaten Israel.

Note NOT threaten Russia and NOT threaten America.

It would in the future but not now. Remember that Hitler was not stupid either. At times Hitler moved with caution and above all one step at a time. He was a clever instinctive leader. So are the crafty Mullahs.

With material at 20 per cent and with thousands of counterfuges ready to go that can be transformed into weapon grade in two simple runs, 20 to 40, 40 to 80 and so on.


The rocketry all set up and ready to go. All questions of ignition etc. already solved.


All that is possible and Obama is fully aware of this.


Part of this situation will be the Obama demand to strip Israel of its Nuclear defence.


Assad fights simply to survive. It has never been his or the Syrain tribes fault that they had to fight to survive against Imperialism and the Sharia…driven into a corner with Iran, and of course Assad still Antisemitic like almost all Arabs…but note his grandfather was not, he was pro-Zionist. This dramatic change has happened inside a generation or so.


The axis is not just Iran…Hizbullah…Assad, it is that PLUS Obama…AND THE FASCIST LEFT which latter includes Stalinism…that is Putin!


What to do…rest assured that Israel will strike against Iran and it will be assisted by Saudi Arabia. The BIG lesson in this is Mubarak. Abdullah will NEVER forgive Obama, Cameron and the Mullahs for the overthrow of Mubarak.


It is not that Netanyahu is brave, it is rather that Israel has no choice if it is to survive. In fact the Saudis also have no choice if they too want to survive.


Jews and socialists must prepare for Israel to make war on Iran and 4international alone on the left will back it unconditionally in every forum in which we have a voice.


As if that was not totally serious enough place it also takes place in the context of revolution against Obama in America. Speaking of revolution expect now many red scares such as that of Diana West and her much discussed book, the red scare of the Daily Mail, and this tempo is going to pick up. There will be many Red Scares and really strange subjects will be accused of being Commies!


That is our times! Accept that and prepare!